It's so much more complicated than that
that this kind of framing digs people in a further confusing hole - I guess it's fine to point out that there's "more than meets the eye" (hence the need for there to be the 'shoggoth' or the 'she') but the divide into two kind of adds a curiosity stopper to the shape and diversity of the 'mystery' behind the mask

If you'd find this frame too reductive for talking about humans, the same goes for LLMs